Mitcham Christian who refused to work on Sundays loses Court of Appeal battle

Your Local Guardian: Celestina Mba claimed Merton Council had discriminated against her and forced her out of her job by making her work on Sundays Celestina Mba claimed Merton Council had discriminated against her and forced her out of her job by making her work on Sundays

A devout Christian who claimed she was illegally forced out of her job after refusing to work on Sundays has lost her case in the Court of Appeal.

Celestina Mba, a former Merton care worker at Brightwell Children’s centre in Morden, claimed Merton Council had agreed that she would not have to work on Sundays due to her beliefs, but later went back on their promise by allocating her Sunday shifts and threatening disciplinary measures if she did not comply.

Miss Mba, from Mitcham, took her case to an employment tribunal in February 2012 claiming constructive dismissal and that the council had unlawfully discriminated against her.

However the judge ruled in the council’s favour claiming that having Sunday's off work was "not a core component of Christian faith".

Later that decision was upheld Mr Justice Langstaff at the High Court in December 13, 2012, leading Miss Mba to take her case to the Court of Appeal where her case was heard on October 23.

Today the Court of Appeal ruled in favour of Merton Council dismissing Miss Mba's claims but did recognise that for many Sunday observance is a valid expression of their faith and admitted their had been "legal errors" in the testing Merton Council's decision.

Councillor Stephen Alambritis, leader of Merton Council said: "We are pleased with the outcome of this case.

"Children in local authority care who have severe disabilities and who need weekend support, and their families who rely on this support, can feel reassured that their children’s care and support will be consistent.

"It is vital that these children are looked after by carers who are familiar with their needs and are available to provide round the clock care over the weekend.

"Wherever possible, we accommodate our employees’ needs and requirements.

"Councils like Merton provide many services during the week and at weekends, and we work to rotas to ensure we have suitable staff on duty at all times and that the rotas are fair and lawful for employees."

Following the decision Miss Mba, said: "They were trying to break my faith and see if I really believed in the Lord’s Day. "Merton disrespected my Christian faith.

"I said to the Court that the Council would not treat other faiths like they treat Christians. "It was like giving pork to a Muslim every meal-time and then disciplining them for not eating it.

"If they really needed someone to work on a Sunday, they should have recruited that person and I would have been glad to leave.

"I had offered to take unpopular shifts and work anti-socials in order to protect Sundays."

Despite the case's dismissal the Christian Legal Centre, which has supported Miss Mba throughout, claimed it was a "big step forward".

Andrea Minichiello Williams, barrister and director of the Christian Legal Centre, said: "We believe if the Court of Appeal had been prepared to consider the facts according to the correct test, Celestina would have won.

"The onus should be on the employer to reasonably accommodate their employee.

"However, this judgement is a big step forward for proper treatment of Christians and is an important victory.

"At last the courts are beginning to demonstrate greater understanding of what it means to be a Christian.

"Christian identity extends beyond private belief into daily life.

"We pray that the tide is turning."

Comments (2)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

2:29pm Thu 5 Dec 13

Hove Ex-Pat says...

Good decision. Who did she think would look after those children? Just leave them alone until Monday? She keeps quoting Jesus when she is on TV. I think he would want you to care for those who cannot care for themselves. Also Ms Mba, please do not get on a bus or tube on your way to your church, or go into a shop either, because there will be people working on a Sunday, & you would not want to take advantage of that, would you?
Good decision. Who did she think would look after those children? Just leave them alone until Monday? She keeps quoting Jesus when she is on TV. I think he would want you to care for those who cannot care for themselves. Also Ms Mba, please do not get on a bus or tube on your way to your church, or go into a shop either, because there will be people working on a Sunday, & you would not want to take advantage of that, would you? Hove Ex-Pat
  • Score: 3

10:35am Fri 6 Dec 13

mangad says...

Absolutely. If this case had gone her way, the repercussions could have been huge - what if every care worker suddenly demanded not to work on a Sunday? Or a nurse, doctor, police offer, fireman?

The fact is that some jobs involve work on Sundays. If you don't like that, don't apply for the job in the first place. Simple.
Absolutely. If this case had gone her way, the repercussions could have been huge - what if every care worker suddenly demanded not to work on a Sunday? Or a nurse, doctor, police offer, fireman? The fact is that some jobs involve work on Sundays. If you don't like that, don't apply for the job in the first place. Simple. mangad
  • Score: 3

Comments are closed on this article.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree