Road chicanes put cyclists 'in line of fire' in Martin Way, Morden

Your Local Guardian: Unsafe: Cylists Richard Evans, Frank Collins, Neil Guthrie and Hugh Morgan in Martin Way, Morden Unsafe: Cylists Richard Evans, Frank Collins, Neil Guthrie and Hugh Morgan in Martin Way, Morden

Cyclists have savaged the creators of a “patently dangerous” traffic system in a damning report.

Merton Cycling Campaign (MCC) examined controversial road changes in Martin Way, Morden, which caused outrage when they were introduced in 2007.

The system of chicanes was partially removed last year after a flood of complaints.

MCC’s report called the system “patently dangerous” and criticised Merton Council for introducing the scheme, and a safety audit carried out by Transport for London (TfL).

Report author Hugh Morgan said: “In writing this report I was shocked to discover the lack of standards in the road safety auditing procedure.

“We have seen the results of this first-hand in Merton, and paid heavily for the auditors’ mistakes."

The system introduced five traffic islands to create chicanes, intended to slow traffic down.

But at the chicane points, bicycles were briefly diverted from the main road into a bypass – before being pushed back into it in a way cyclists claim was hugely dangerous.

Your Local Guardian: Road chicanes put cyclists 'in line of fire'

The MCC argued the council-designed system put riders “in the line of fire”, and that a cyclist entering it in busy traffic “would have to be suicidal”.

The scheme was checked by TfL’s auditors, who criticised it, but the MCC said their suggestion for fixing the problem – to adjust the kerb size – was both ridiculous and lethal.

The MCC said both bodies had allowed the design to pass through a safety audit process despite key documents being missing or incomplete – and neither took reasonable care to ensure the system was not dangerous.

All of the controversial bicycle bypasses and three of the five islands were removed in May 2010.

A TfL spokesman disputed the report's findings – saying his organisation had made recommendations to change the scheme which were not taken up, and a complaint against TfL about the matter was not upheld by the Local Government Ombudsman.

Merton Council's cabinet member for environmental sustainability and regeneration, Councillor Andrew Judge, said: “Merton’s road safety record is one of the best in London. "This is largely due to the council’s careful and considered planning of its traffic calming measures.

“An independent safety audit was conducted to ensure the chicanes in Martin Way meet the required safety standards. “We go to great lengths to ensure that all our traffic calming measures contribute to the safety of all road users, including cyclists.”


What do you think? Leave a comment below or contact Craig by calling 020 8722 6336; tweeting @Craig_Burnett or emailing: cburnett@london.newsquest.co.uk.

Comments (3)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

10:39am Wed 30 Nov 11

Fredellis says...

I agree with MCC's comments. I cycled down Martin Way just after the chicanes were installed and couldn't understand why the council had made the road more dangerous.
I work as a cycle trainer and don't think I could advise anyone to use this stretch of road.
I agree with MCC's comments. I cycled down Martin Way just after the chicanes were installed and couldn't understand why the council had made the road more dangerous. I work as a cycle trainer and don't think I could advise anyone to use this stretch of road. Fredellis
  • Score: 0

3:54pm Wed 30 Nov 11

tjames says...

fredellis--because they can.

masses of things have no beneficial function but increases "responsibilities" and hence non-job prospects
fredellis--because they can. masses of things have no beneficial function but increases "responsibilities" and hence non-job prospects tjames
  • Score: 0

2:22pm Fri 2 Dec 11

Angela M says...

Having driven down this road with my husband, I find it terrifying. And I certainly wouldn't dare to ride my bike on this road in its current layout!
Having driven down this road with my husband, I find it terrifying. And I certainly wouldn't dare to ride my bike on this road in its current layout! Angela M
  • Score: 0

Comments are closed on this article.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree