Carshalton quartet spared jail despite attack on cancer-sufferer

Quartet spared jail despite attack on cancer-suffering relative

Quartet spared jail despite attack on cancer-suffering relative

First published in News by , Chief Reporter

Four women have narrowly dodged jail after beating up a cancer-suffering relative when a family feud erupted at a school car boot sale.

Linda Smith, 47, her daughter Eliza, 21, both of Woodmansterne Road, attacked their cousin Louise Green at St Philomena’s School, in Carshalton, in April 2009.

Minty Smith, 47, and daughter Rosie, 19, of The Pastures, Banstead, were part of the group and were also found guilty of actual bodily harm and affray.

Judge John Anderson, sitting at Croydon Crown Court on Monday, branded the quartet as “disgusting” before handing down a six-month suspended prison sentence.

He said: “You four women embarked on a screaming, hysterical attack in a public place.

"Your victim was recovering from cancer treament and was with her seven-year-old son.

“This was part of a long-running dispute. You ran and attacked her punching and pulling her hair, even when the police arrived you were still eager to continue.

“The only reason you are not going to prison is the minimal injuries.

"Having heard the evidence it is clear this was a set up and a pre-meditated assault.

“This was a disgusting spectacle and would have affected hundreds of people that day - all of you were utterly foul-mouthed and abusive.”

Related links

During the trial, the jury heard that Mrs Green’s husband, Terry, had approached the four defendants at the car boot sale after posters announcing his wife’s breast cancer were circulated around Carshalton.

Mr Green had spent six months in custody in 2008 after “wild and malicious” allegations were relayed to police by the Smith family.

It was after this spell in custody that the alleged poster campaign began against Mrs Green where crudely edited photographs of the mother-of-three with a breast cut out were posted in the surrounding area.

The Smiths, who must also pay court costs of £800, were ordered not to re-offend within an 18-month period or they would have to serve their suspended sentences.

Linda, Rosie and Eliza must complete 80 hours of unpaid work in the next 12 months and Minty was handed a 3-month curfew meang she must remain in her caravan between 7pm and 6am every day.

One of the defendants, Linda, tried to argue that she should not face unpaid work because she was illiterate - a request that was dismissed by Judge Anderson.

Comments (3)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

12:14pm Tue 25 Jan 11

theavengers says...

Shame how many women behave these days. Not ladies at all, and as we see, when a person isn't a lady and has daughters, they act just like her. Like a disease of stupidity passed down from generation to generation. These women need to put on some clean clothes, get a job, and not have so much time on their hands to make others lives hell. Really not surprised they live in caravans, can't read, and don't pay taxes. Just look at them for gods sake! A total drag on society.
Shame how many women behave these days. Not ladies at all, and as we see, when a person isn't a lady and has daughters, they act just like her. Like a disease of stupidity passed down from generation to generation. These women need to put on some clean clothes, get a job, and not have so much time on their hands to make others lives hell. Really not surprised they live in caravans, can't read, and don't pay taxes. Just look at them for gods sake! A total drag on society. theavengers
  • Score: 0

5:44pm Wed 26 Jan 11

thedarkman says...

These people are a waste to the human population. They seem to me that they need a good bath!! and kick up there own behinds and get a job instead of us paying for there benefits... These people need to learn a lesson in life.... what goes around comes around !!!! My relative died of cancer and for these people to attack a lady who suffered from this are very sick and twisted people. I hope that i have the pleasure of meeting these people so i can give them a piece of my mind... I cant say what i want to say to you lot of scrongers i bet your all on benefits ..... scrongers ....
These people are a waste to the human population. They seem to me that they need a good bath!! and kick up there own behinds and get a job instead of us paying for there benefits... These people need to learn a lesson in life.... what goes around comes around !!!! My relative died of cancer and for these people to attack a lady who suffered from this are very sick and twisted people. I hope that i have the pleasure of meeting these people so i can give them a piece of my mind... I cant say what i want to say to you lot of scrongers i bet your all on benefits ..... scrongers .... thedarkman
  • Score: 0

8:28pm Sun 30 Jan 11

BevHalstead says...

I was at the carboot just as the police arrived. These women were aggressive, rude and offensive, as were the men folk involved.

Sunday morning, a car boot at a catholic school - they should all have been locked up.
I was at the carboot just as the police arrived. These women were aggressive, rude and offensive, as were the men folk involved. Sunday morning, a car boot at a catholic school - they should all have been locked up. BevHalstead
  • Score: 0

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree